(740) 548-6334

Join Us for Lunch and Dinner in a Casual, Fun Restaurant

Looking for a nice place to get a great home-cooked lunch or dinner at great prices? Bring the whole family to Cheshire Market Pizza and Subs for a fun, casual and delicious dining experience. We’re family owned and ready to treat your family right, with a great selection of pizzas (with three choices of pizza sauces – mild, mixed or spicy, and your favorite meat and veggie toppings), subs, salads, appetizers, our all-you-can-eat pizza and salad bar on Thursdays, and Spaghetti Night on Tuesday. Stop by anytime for great food and outstanding service. We serve Galena, Westerville, Lewis Center, Sunbury and Delaware. We can’t wait to serve you!

And when you need snacks and necessities, you’ll find them at Cheshire Market – your one-stop convenience store!


Garlic Bread with Cheese
Open faced sub bun with butter, garlic, and provolone cheese and choice
of pizza sauce
Whole $6.99
Half $3.99
New Larger Chicken Wings!!!
Try our meatier wings served plain or with BBQ, or buffalo sauce and served
with celery, and choice of Ranch or Blue Cheese dressing
Whole $8.99
Half $4.99
Potato Skins
Six Potato Skins with sour cream
Whole $6.99
Half $3.99
Tim's Hot Skins
Potato skins with Hot sauce
Whole $6.99
Half $3.99
Cheese Filled Bread Sticks
Three bread sticks served with marinara sauce
Chicken Tender Basket
Six breaded Chicken Tenders with your choice of sauce. (BBQ, Buffalo, Ranch,
Blue Cheese, Honey Mustard)


Garden Salad
Iceberg lettuce, onion, green peppers, and tomato
Large $5.99
Small $3.99
Anti-pasta Salad
Garden salad plus provolone cheese, black olives, and hot peppers
Large $6.99
Small $4.79
Chef Salad
Same as anti-pasta plus cubes of ham and American cheese
Large $7.79
Small $5.49
Chicken "Milt" Salad
Garden salad with Colby-jack cheese, your choice of grilled or breaded chicken
Large $7.99
Small $5.99


Cheese $7.79 $9.99 $11.79
1 Item $8.79 $11.19 $13.49
2 Item $9.79 $12.49 $14.99
3 Item $10.79 $13.69 $16.49
4 Item $11.79 $14.99 $17.99
ATW $12.79 $15.99 $18.99
Extra Cheese $1.29 $1.49 $1.79
*Served with choice of three pizza sauces: mild, mixed, or spicy.
Pizza toppings: ham, pepperoni, sausage, onion, mushrooms, green peppers,
hot peppers, tomato, black olives, pineapple, jalapenos, green olives, bacon,
and anchovies
*Gluten free available in 12" crust, add $1.00*
Add Grilled Chicken: 10" - $1.99
12" - $2.49
14" - $2.99

A pizza crust filled with provolone cheese and a choice of one item
Extra items $.29 ea. for small, $.49 ea. for large
Large $11.99
Small $6.49
Spaghetti Night
Spaghetti and meatballs, tossed salad, and garlic bread *Tuesday only
Adult $8.49
Kids $4.79
Pizza Buffet
All you can eat pizza and salad bar *Thursday only
Adult $8.99
Kids $4.79
Lunch Pizza Buffet
*Tuesday & Thursday only 10:00am - 2:00pm


Italian Sub
Genoa salami, ham, pepperoni, capicola ham, provolone cheese. Topped with fresh lettuce, tomato, banana peppers and Italian dressing.
Whole $7.99
Half $4.99
Double Italian
Twice the meat and cheese of our regular sub.
Whole $9.49
Half $5.99
NEW  Chicken Parmesan
Our breaded chicken breast rest on our 12" hoagie smothered in spaghetti sauce and provolone.
Whole $8.99
Ham n Cheese
Our deli-sliced ham with your choice of cheese. Topped with fresh lettuce, tomato and onion.
Whole $7.99
Half $4.99
All our veggies piled high on our fresh baked sub bun with Italian dressing and American & provolone cheese.
Whole $7.99
Half $4.99
NEW  Italian Chicken
Our breaded chicken breast topped with provolone and oven-baked on our 12" bun. Topped off with crisp lettuce, tomato, onion, banana peppers and Italian dressing.
Whole $8.99
NEW Buffalo Chicken Sub
Breaded chicken breast Buffalo-style with onion, lettuce, tomato and provolone cheese. Topped with your choice of ranch or bleu cheese on our 12" sub bun.
Whole $8.99
Half $4.99
Pizza Sub
Our 12" open faced sub covered in pizza sauce, provolone cheese and your favorite (After two items add .25 for each item)
Whole $7.99
Half $4.99
Turkey Club
Deli sliced turkey, provolone cheese, crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion and mayo.
Whole $7.99
Half $4.99
Oven baked meatballs with spaghetti sauce and provolone cheese.
Whole $7.99
Half $4.99


Coke Products, Bottled Beer, Wine & Coolers